Columbus was unable to break down Ilya Bryzgalov on Tuesday, firing 40 shots but scoring only 3 times in a 4-3 loss against the Coyotes.
Phoenix won as a +116 underdog, while Over-Under bettors who played OVER the total of 5.5 were rewarded at the payout window.
Derek Morris, Eric Belanger, Radim Vrbata, and Vernon Fiddler each scored for the Coyotes in the victory. Fiddler opened the scoring for Phoenix, finding the back of the net at 2:14 of the second period. The goal was assisted by Lauri Korpikoski.
Ilya Bryzgalov stopped 37 of 40 Columbus shots in the victory.
Kristian Huselius, Rostislav Klesla, and Jared Boll scored for the Blue Jackets, finding the net behind Ilya Bryzgalov.
Mathieu Garon stopped 24 of 28 shots for the Blue Jackets, but it wasn't enough to earn the victory.
On the power play, Phoenix went 1-for-4, while the Blue Jackets were 1-for-5 with the man advantage.
Columbus outshot Phoenix 40-28 in the game.
Phoenix looks to continue their winning ways next game with a battle against the Maple Leafs. The Blue Jackets will aim to get back on the winning track vs Detroit.