Craig Anderson stopped 37 of 39 shots fired at him by Toronto, as the Senators skated to a 3-2 victory Tuesday at Air Canada Centre.
The Senators were a +125 underdog in the win. The combined score dipped UNDER the total, which closed at 5.5.
Daniel Alfredsson, Jason Spezza, and Kyle Turris each scored for the Senators in the victory. Alfredsson opened the scoring for Ottawa, finding the back of the net at 19:52 of the first period. The goal was assisted by Milan Michalek and Kyle Turris.
Craig Anderson turned in a 37-save effort for the Senators.
Joffrey Lupul and Matthew Lombardi scored for the Maple Leafs, finding the net behind Craig Anderson.
James Reimer stopped 18 of 21 shots for the Maple Leafs, but it wasn't enough to earn the victory.
Ottawa scored 0 times on 1 chances on the power play, while Toronto went 0-for-2 with the man advantage.
Toronto outshot Ottawa 39-21 in the game.
Ottawa heads into a battle against the Sharks. Toronto, meanwhile, will have their next action against Minnesota.