New York earned a 5-2 victory over Toronto behind a 2-goal performance from Matt Moulson on Tuesday at Air Canada Centre.
New York won as a +100 underdog, while Over-Under bettors who played OVER the total of 5.5 were rewarded at the payout window.
New York got goals from Matt Moulson (2), P.A. Parenteau, Josh Bailey, and David Ullstrom in the victory. Bailey opened the scoring at 15:34 of the first period.
Evgeni Nabokov turned in a 12-save effort for the Islanders.
Matthew Lombardi and Phil Kessel scored for the Maple Leafs, finding the net behind Evgeni Nabokov.
James Reimer stopped 29 of 33 shots for the Maple Leafs, but it wasn't enough to earn the victory.
New York scored 1 time on 4 chances on the power play, while Toronto went 0-for-1 with the man advantage.
Toronto lost the shots on goal battle to New York by a margin of 34-14.
New York heads into a battle against the Lightning. Toronto, meanwhile, will have their next action against New Jersey.