The New York Yankees (95-59) and Toronto Blue Jays (87-68) finish off their three-game set at Rogers Centre on Wednesday. The Yankees are 8-1 in their last nine contests while the Blue Jays are 3-1 over their last four games. Find out if New York can stay hot in our Yankees vs Blue Jays prediction.

Bet On Jays vs Yankees Here

Yankees vs Blue Jays Betting Preview

Yankees vs Blue Jays Opening Odds

The Yankees opened as the road favorite at -125 on the moneyline with the Blue Jays coming in at +105. The total was set at 7.5 runs with the OVER going 5-0 in the last five meetings between the two clubs. New York has won 10 of the last 14 meetings at Rogers Centre, making the visitors the clear favorites in our Yankees vs Blue Jays prediction.

Get the best Yankees vs Blue Jays odds and lines available from our recommended sportsbooks for your favorite picks of the night.

  • Best Spread
  • Best Moneyline
  • Best Total

Starting Pitchers 

Mitch White (1-6) lasted just four innings in his last start against the Tampa Bay Rays on September 23, giving up five hits and three earned runs in a no-decision. The Blue Jays starter has a 5.12 ERA and a 1.41 WHIP in 91.1 innings of work.

Gerrit Cole (12-7) took a no-decision in his last outing on September 23 against the Boston Red Sox after allowing five hits and four earned runs in six innings. The right-hander has a 3.49 ERA and a 1.03 WHIP over 188.1 innings this season.

Yankees Clinch AL East Title

The Yankees picked up a 5-2 win over the Blue Jays in the second meeting of their series on Tuesday night to clinch the AL East title – their first since 2019 and second in the last 10 seasons. Gleyber Torres led the way offensively with three RBIs – all by way of RBI singles.

The home run watch continues for Aaron Judge, who had four walks and no hits on Tuesday. The Yankees slugger is sitting at 60 on the season, one shy of Roger Maris’ American League record, though he’s now gone without a homer in seven straight games.

Jays Lose But Guerrero Stays Hot

After a big extra-innings win in the series opener Monday, the Blue Jays fell on Tuesday after a poor start from Jose Berrios, who surrendered nine hits and five earned runs over 5.1 innings. George Springer hit his 24th homer of the year while Vladimir Guerrero Jr. added an RBI single.

After a slow start to the month, Guerrero has picked up some steam over the last week and a half with two home runs and eight RBIs in nine games. Center-fielder Whit Merrifield has also been a surprise standout with three homers and six RBIs in his last six outings.

Yankees Player Prop: Judge To Hit A Home Run (+225)

With so much buzz around Judge’s home run chase, it’s only fitting to bet on the Yankees slugger. Judge is getting +225 on Wednesday to hit his record-setting home run, and with White on the mound for Toronto, it could be the night.

Blue Jays Player Prop: Guerrero OVER 3 Hits + Runs + RBIs (+106)

Guerrero has been very productive of late, entering the contest on a three-game hit and RBI streak. You can get him at +106 to record at least three combined hits, runs and RBIs on Wednesday night.

Yankees: Keys To Win

The Yankees are set up for success with Cole on the mound while they’re coming up against a weaker starter in White. Cole hasn’t been on his A-game of late, giving up four earned runs in each of his last three starts, but if he can get back on track, New York should cruise to a win.

Blue Jays: Keys To Win

While the Blue Jays have won three of their last four contests, their offense has dried up a bit as the club is scoring just 3.75 runs per game over that span. They’ll need to do better than that if they’re going to defeat the Yankees, who own the second-best offense in the majors.

MLB Computer Pick: OVER 7.5 Runs

Check out more of our signature MLB computer picks, plus our favorite sportsbooks that serve baseball customers. 

Join A Top-Tier MLB Betting Site Now

Shark Bites
  • The OVER is 13-6 in New York’s last 19 games.
  • Toronto is 5-2 in the last 7 meetings.
  • The UNDER is 14-6 in New York’s last 20 road games.
Flag Our Top Sportsbooks
*Terms and Conditions apply to all bonus offers on this website. Please visit operator for details.
Top Pick
125% BONUS Up To $2500
Top Pick
50% BONUS Up To $1000
Top Pick
50% BONUS Up To $1000
Top Pick
50% BONUS Up To $1000
Top Pick
100% BONUS Up To $1000