MLB Parlay Picks: Baseball Parlay Bets Today

All it takes is one! We're back and better than ever with our MLB parlay picks.

Here are your MLB parlay picks for today's baseball games, as well as a profit tracker for our experts' recent selections:

It’s Tuesday, September 16, and instead of our usual NRFI or prop singles, we’re locking in a same-game parlay for Dodgers vs Phillies. With three legs that lean on scorching bats, fading a superstar, and trusting a Cy Young candidate, this one lines up at tasty +372 odds. Let’s break it down.

MLB Same-Game Parlay: Dodgers vs Phillies (+372 at Sportsbook)

Dodgers vs Phillies Odds – 10:10 p.m. ET

Leg 1: Kyle Schwarber OVER 0.5 Total Bases (-145)

Let’s start with the hottest hitter in baseball. Kyle Schwarber has homered in three straight games — two in Kansas City and another against these very Dodgers on Monday night. He’s cleared 0.5 total bases in seven consecutive contests, making this line at -145 borderline shocking. Sure, Shohei Ohtani is a daunting matchup, but Schwarber only needs one knock, and his recent barrel rate suggests he’s due for another loud swing. This is tremendous value for our first leg.

Leg 2: Shohei Ohtani UNDER 1.5 Total Bases (-160)

As great as Ohtani is on the mound, he’s cooled at the plate. He’s gone under this total in six of his last 10 games, and the matchup with Christopher Sanchez isn’t favorable. Ohtani is just 3-for-13 lifetime against Sanchez, with all three hits being singles and four strikeouts sprinkled in. With Sanchez locked in as one of the NL’s top lefties and the added lefty-lefty challenge, fading Ohtani’s bat feels like a sharp play. At -160, this under adds balance to our parlay.

Leg 3: Christopher Sanchez OVER 17.5 Outs (-140)

Finally, we back Sanchez himself. The Phillies southpaw has been nothing short of sensational, delivering the OVER on 17.5 outs in nine of his last 10 starts. He consistently works deep into games, showing command and efficiency that let him finish six innings with ease. Against a Dodgers lineup that his left-handed stuff could neutralize, Sanchez is in a prime spot to extend his streak. This leg ties the parlay together by leaning into his reliability and matchup advantage.

Altogether, this three-leg parlay pays out at approximately +372. Between Schwarber’s power surge, Ohtani’s dip in production, and Sanchez’s steady excellence, this is a same-game combo that brings both narrative and numbers together.