Today’s MLB player props focus on two quietly consistent bats in underrated matchups. I’m backing Brandon Marsh to stay hot against a familiar foe and Orlando Arcia to keep producing in Colorado’s thin lineup.
Below, find our best MLB player prop bets for Monday, June 16, 2025:
MLB Player Props Today
Brandon Marsh OVER 0.5 Total Bases (-170 at Sportsbook)
Marsh isn’t the flashiest name in the Phillies lineup, but he’s been one of the most consistent lately—hitting safely in six straight games heading into Monday night’s action.
He faces Sandy Alcantara, who’s been strong over his last couple of starts but still owns an ugly 8.47 ERA through his first 11 games. Marsh has historically handled Alcantara well, going 5-for-19 with three singles, two doubles, and just two strikeouts. He’s locked in, and this matchup gives him a great shot to cash this number early.
At -170, it’s chalky but fair for a high-floor play. This bet is also a strong candidate to include in a parlay.
Orlando Arcia OVER 0.5 Total Bases (-150 at Sportsbook)
Orlando Arcia may have fallen out of the spotlight since his All-Star days in Atlanta, but the veteran infielder has quietly found some rhythm in Colorado.
He’s riding a five-game hit streak and draws a solid matchup against Nationals starter Jake Irvin, against whom Arcia is 2-for-10 with a double and a home run, plus no strikeouts in the split, which is a strong sign of comfort at the plate.
At -150, this is another steady pick with a proven floor. Given both players' recent form, a small-unit parlay could offer a nice boost if you're feeling bold.
